There are two reasons why I don't rate this 5 stars. It is historically incorrect in several parts. For instance, Fred Astaire sang Night And Day on Broadway, not some guy named Jack. And there is a bit too much about the sex life of Porter. I just fast forward past those scenes and watch the musical numbers, which are great. People who complain about the arrangements are off the wall. This was made in 2004, why should they rehash the same old arrangements? The music is great and the sound and staging is beautiful. The CD is also terrific. We loved it. If you like musicals and you like classic songs, you'll enjoy it, as long as you truly believe that someone else besides Sinatra and Ella can perform these songs!