"Battle In Heaven", Carlos Reygadas' follow-up to "Japón", opens with a controversial oral sex scene involving beauty, Ana (Anapola Mushkadiz), and the beast, Marcos (Marcos Hernández). Marcos is Ana's chauffeur, who has kidnapped and accidentally killed a baby. Ana, a general's daughter by day and a prostitute by night, confides in Marcos and performs sexual favors for him in order to persuade him to turn himself in. She is too young, however, to understand Marcos's confused mental state, and her sensitive position with him puts her in peril. Set in Mexico City, this tragic drama is as much about failed intimacy as it is about Mexican class structure, as Ana and Marcos attempt to bridge the class gap. A few explicit sex scenes show Marcos in bed with Ana or his wife (Bertha Ruiz), thus garnering it reviews that compare it to "The Brown Bunny". In fact, the slow pacing and artsy, self-consciously composed shots do remind one of "The Brown Bunny", in that both films are initially interesting but grow dull as their plots take forever to unfold. An intriguing plot is buried under seemingly eternal panoramic shots of the city, painfully slow conversation between characters, and constant close-ups of Marcos' face that are meant to capture his angst but only deter narrative. Nevertheless, this film's merit is based in its experimental energy, and any director who follows up a graphic sex scene with a cut to the waving of the country's flag (in this case Mexico's) has my respect. "--Trinie Dalton"